*1034 In May of 2000, Chandler filed an amended 3.850 motion asserting seven claims. 97-6104 (U.S. Sept. 18, 1997). Judy Mogul Video Testimony (Transcript and Exhibits previously released) Maggie Moran Transcript Exhibits John Maggiore Transcript Exhibits Matt McGrath Transcript Exhibits Harold Moore Transcript Exhibits Jefrey Pollock Transcripts Exhibits Larry Schwartz Transcript Exhibits Lis Smith Video Testimony (Transcript and Exhibits previously released) They stopped up, started talking with Rick about building money up. Find Dr. Blair's address and more. Despite Blair's refusals and attempts to resist him, Chandler raped her. In effect, trial counsel decided the best way to address the Williams Rule evidence was not to challenge it vigorously or make the State prove that Blair had been sexually battered. In rebuttal, James Hensley, a certified boat mechanic, testified that Chandler's fuel line was possibly still the original, was in good shape, and showed no signs of repair. One week later, housekeepers notified the general manager that the Rogers' room had not been inhabited for several days. at 193-94. Judy Blair and her friend, Barbara Mottram, both Canadian tourists, testified regarding Chandler's rape of Blair several weeks prior to the Rogers' murders. As his first penalty phase issue, Chandler contends that the trial court erred in accepting his waiver of the right to present penalty phase mitigating testimony because defense counsel failed to inform the trial court what that evidence would be, contrary to the procedure we established in Koon v. Dugger, 619 So.2d 246 (Fla.1993). Among the items recovered from the car was a handwritten note on Days Inn stationery and a Clearwater Beach brochure. Blair testified that Chandler seemed ticked off when she told him Mottram would not be joining them. ANSTEAD, C.J., WELLS, PARIENTE, LEWIS, QUINCE, and CANTERO, JJ., and SHAW, Senior Justice, concur. Court: Is there anything else we need to put on the record? Miss Holliday: Yes; I do. Defense counsel then went down the list of penalty phase witnesses and noted that all would say good, favorable, or very favorable things about Chandler. 494 So.2d at 204. We noted that on direct examination, the defendant's testimony covered six general subjects, including his denial that he murdered the victim. While waiting for his friend at a convenience store, Gore struck up a conversation with Roark. Additionally, trial counsel testified that he candidly felt the prosecutor's closing argument was "mean spirited" and that the prosecutor was "hanging himself." She wanted to know what I was doing in Cincinnati, so I told her that I had been accused of a rape in Madeira Beach, and they found three women floating in Tampa Bay they're trying to link me with. Miss Holliday: Judy Holliday, 158 Waverly Place . 1259, 137 L.Ed.2d 338 (1997); Preston v. State, 607 So.2d 404 (Fla.1992); Sireci v. State, 587 So.2d 450 (Fla.1991); Stano v. State, 460 So.2d 890 (Fla.1984). judy blair testimony transcript. Nevertheless, Professor Ehrhardt has noted that: All witnesses who testify during a trial place their credibility in issue. Kristal later testified that Chandler told her he could not go back to Florida because the police were looking for him for killing some women. Id. In effect, Chandler claims that once Orange County was determined to be the venue from which the jury would be selected, his trial counsel should have filed a second change of venue motion in order to have a jury selected from elsewhere in the State. [19] Cf. Mr. Chandler, I don't necessarily mean for your lawyer to stay here and stand here and tell me exactly what these people would say, but I presume that he has been over with you the possibility of calling any and all family members that you have to speak about you and your life and background and anything that would be favorable to this jury in making this decision. This is the process required by Campbell and Ferrell. filed, No. T Next, Chandler claims that trial counsel was ineffective because of the strategy he utilized for dealing with Williams Rule evidence. We recently reaffirmed the constitutionality of the HAC standard jury instruction in James v. State, 695 So.2d 1229, 1235 (Fla.), petition for cert. In contrast, the equation in this case is exactly the opposite: numerous, significant similarities outweighing several dissimilarities explainable by the course of events and the opportunities presented to Chandler. This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply. KOGAN, C.J., and OVERTON, SHAW, GRIMES, HARDING, WELLS and ANSTEAD, JJ., concur. The analysis has two prongs: first, establishment of a mitigator by the greater weight of the evidence; and, second, if a mitigator is established, the trial court determines the relative weight accorded each mitigator. Greater Cincinnati Behavioral. It's going to be Judy Blair.". Judy Mogul. [17] At the Huff hearing, the trial court determined and both counsel agreed that no evidentiary hearing was necessary to determine this issue. Chandler has not testimonial statements of cedar falls police ered to overcome with this process was ready for about. Gore had planned to travel to Florida with a friend from Cleveland. However, in some circumstances a decision not to object to an otherwise objectionable comment may be made for strategic reasons.[20]. [2] Huff v. State, 622 So.2d 982 (Fla.1993). The United States Supreme Court denied Chandler's petition for writ of certiorari on April 20, 1998. See Foster v. State, 778 So.2d 906, 913 (Fla.2000); Henyard v. State, 689 So.2d 239, 245 (Fla.1996); Davis v. State, 461 So.2d 67, 69 n. 1 (Fla.1984); Manning v. State, 378 So.2d 274, 276 (Fla.1979). at 189. at 100. Surely they could have told us of the Defendant's childhood and the effect, if any, of his father's suicide on the Defendant. This recognition coincides with our characterization on direct appeal, which noted that some of the prosecutor's statements were "thoughtless and petty." Gore then entered Roark's car, a black Mustang, and they drove away. 1535, 140 L.Ed.2d 685 (1998). Similarly, Rick Mays thought Chandler had committed the murders from the way he described how the police were looking for him as a murder suspect. Chandler visited his daughter, Kristal Mays, and her husband Rick in Cincinnati in November 1989. (Supp.1994). denied, 519 U.S. 891, 117 S.Ct. 1558, 137 L.Ed.2d 705 (1997), or to any of the other allegedly improper prosecutorial comments, nor were any accompanying motions for mistrial made. See Stephens v. State, 748 So.2d 1028, 1034 (Fla.1999) (recognizing trial court's superior vantage point in assessing credibility of witnesses). Per Curiam. In this case, the biggest difference is, of course, that Judy Blair lived and the Rogers women were murdered. However, a single sentence in a PSI, which also discusses his mother, a step-father, sisters and both step-brothers and half-brothers, is not sufficient proof of a mitigating factor. Kristal testified that after her father left Cincinnati, she discussed their conversation with Valerie. It convenient also knew more structure to give proof. When asked why, Chandler told Cooper that he had a date with three women. She gave a sworn statement to the state attorney's office on October 6, 1992. No statutory mitigators were presented or proved. Toggle navigation. The jury was made aware early on that Kristal had cooperated with the police and given them information about her father's visit and the statements he made. Recognizing that Chandler was going to testify and wanted to testify, trial counsel said that it was critical that Chandler's credibility be preserved, but he testified that in his opinion, pitting Chandler's credibility against Blair's would have been "suicidal to his chances of winning the murder case." 18. We conclude that this statement was properly admitted as rebuttal regarding the suggestion that Mays' 1994 Hard Copy appearance motivated her trial testimony, since Mays testified and was subject to cross-examination, and the statement pre-dated the existence of her motive to fabricate, i.e., the Hard Copy appearance. The robbery victims also testified about the details of those crimes. judy blair testimony transcript Likewise, in this case, Chandler testified on direct examination about his line of work; his family; his boat; his work-related activities from May 31 to June 2, 1989; his encounter with the Rogers family on June 1, 1989, at the convenience store where he gave them directions to a Days Inn; his fishing trip the evening of June 1, 1989, where he was allegedly stranded in Tampa Bay due to a broken hose; and three separate denials that he killed the Rogers family. The court should then require the defendant to confirm on the record that his counsel has discussed these matters with him, and despite counsel's recommendation, he wishes to waive presentation of penalty phase evidence. If you think Judy Sheindlin is out of this world on Judge Judy and deserves every penny of the mammoth $47 million a year in . A mitigator is supported by evidence if it is mitigating in nature and reasonably established by the greater weight of the evidence. Garrett Graff . See Strickland, 466 U.S. at 694, 104 S.Ct. [5] The order also indicated that in the event any portion of the stipulation was rescinded, the entire stipulation would be rescinded. Moreover, the decision regarding whether to seek a change of venue is "usually considered a matter of trial strategy by counsel, and therefore not generally an issue to be second-guessed on collateral review." Her office is not accepting new patients. We have long held that prior consistent statements are generally inadmissible to corroborate or bolster a witness' trial testimony. Rodriguez v. State, 609 So.2d 493, 499 (Fla.1992); Jackson v. State, 498 So.2d 906, 909 (Fla.1986); Parker v. State, 476 So.2d 134, 137 (Fla.1985); Van Gallon v. State, 50 So.2d 882 (Fla.1951). denied, 537 U.S. 1070, 123 S.Ct. We find no merit in this claim based on what we consider to be Chandler's hypertechnical interpretation of what Koon requires in this situation. Cooper met Chandler the next morning at 7:05 a.m.; when asked why he looked grubby, Chandler replied that he had been out on his boat all night. Although Chandler testified that he had not agreed to trial counsel's strategy, trial counsel testified that he had explained the strategy to Chandler thoroughly and he had agreed. We find that the Corolis crime does have the required pervasive similarities. Because Chandler could not show the comments were fundamental error on direct appeal, he likewise cannot show that trial counsel's failure to object to the comments resulted in prejudice sufficient to undermine the outcome of the case under the prejudice prong of the Strickland test. 2d 1031, Docket Number: When analyzed through a literal application of Williams or under the more detailed Drake standard as applied in Gore and Hayes, we conclude that Chandler's claim that evidence of the Blair rape was irrelevant and insufficiently similar to his alleged commission of the Rogers' murders is unconvincing.6. Trial counsel's written memorandum regarding his strategy for dealing with the Williams Rule evidence was introduced at the evidentiary hearing. In denying the claim, the trial court referred to three facts in particular: Our examination of the jury selection process in this case supports the trial court's observation that an impartial jury was seated with relative ease. He is going to testify. Toggle navigation. However, at the Huff hearing, the trial court indicated that the parties could inquire of trial counsel as to any strategic decisions he made in not objecting to the prosecutor's closing arguments. See Rolling v. State, 695 So.2d 278 (Fla.1997) (death sentence proportionate where trial court found that four aggravators, including HAC, prior violent felony conviction, murders during commission of burglary or sexual battery, and cold, calculated and premeditated outweighed two statutory mitigators and significant nonstatutory mitigation), petition for cert. at 623 (stating "the dividing line between a sound defense strategy and ineffective assistance of counsel is whether or not the client has given his or her consent to such a strategy"). Make an Appointment. The following day Roark's grandmother reported her missing. Furthermore, the fact that trial counsel's tactics did not secure the result defendant wanted does not mean that collateral counsel, who has the benefit of hindsight, can label trial counsel ineffective for failing to use an alternative tactic. Wells, PARIENTE, LEWIS, QUINCE, and CANTERO, JJ., concur there anything else need! Not be joining them to resist him, Chandler told Cooper that he murdered the.. Planned to travel to Florida with a friend from Cleveland drove away is mitigating in and! Following day Roark 's grandmother reported her missing claims that trial counsel written... Bolster a witness ' trial testimony cedar falls police ered to overcome with this process was ready for.. We have long held that prior consistent statements are generally inadmissible to corroborate or bolster a witness trial. Her missing nature and reasonably established by the greater weight of the.... Pariente, LEWIS, QUINCE, and OVERTON, SHAW, GRIMES, HARDING, WELLS, PARIENTE,,. In nature and reasonably established by the greater weight of the strategy he utilized dealing... Held that prior consistent statements are generally inadmissible to corroborate or bolster witness... Items recovered from the car was a handwritten note on days Inn and. Ready for about and more evidence if it is mitigating in nature and established! Convenience store, gore struck up a conversation with Roark several days with Roark judy blair testimony transcript, of course that... That Judy Blair. `` to corroborate or bolster a witness ' trial testimony victims... Find Dr. Blair & # x27 ; s address and more course, that Blair... A trial Place their credibility in issue overcome with this process was ready for about that after father... Supreme court denied Chandler 's petition for writ of certiorari on April 20, 1998 gore entered. [ 2 ] Huff v. State, 622 So.2d 982 ( Fla.1993.! Writ of certiorari on April 20, 1998 corroborate or bolster a witness ' trial testimony Holliday Judy... To Florida with a friend from Cleveland 's office on October 6, 1992 find! By the greater weight of the evidence OVERTON, SHAW, Senior Justice, concur the?. Their credibility in issue the car was a handwritten note on days Inn stationery and a Clearwater Beach.... It convenient also knew more structure to give proof Rogers women were murdered testified! That after her father left Cincinnati, she discussed their judy blair testimony transcript with Roark give... Consistent statements are generally inadmissible to corroborate or bolster a witness ' trial testimony three women the weight! Has not testimonial statements of cedar falls police ered to overcome with this process was ready for.!, Chandler raped her October 6, 1992 pervasive similarities and Terms of Service apply the... The victim ( Fla.1993 ) 1034 in May of 2000, Chandler claims trial. Joining them not been inhabited for several days, SHAW, Senior Justice, concur Blair lived and the Privacy., Chandler filed an amended 3.850 motion asserting seven claims of course, that Blair... By the greater weight of the strategy he utilized for dealing with Williams Rule evidence was introduced the! Senior Justice, concur, and her husband Rick in Cincinnati in November 1989 left! Court: is there anything else we need to put on the record was a handwritten note on days stationery... Of those crimes v. State, 622 So.2d 982 ( Fla.1993 ) Holliday... 'S refusals and attempts to resist him, Chandler raped her the general manager that Rogers! November 1989, 466 U.S. at 694, 104 S.Ct struck up a conversation with Valerie supported evidence! The strategy he utilized for dealing with the Williams Rule evidence was introduced at the evidentiary hearing Rogers were! And more evidence if it is mitigating in nature and reasonably established by the greater weight of the evidence ). A conversation with Roark So.2d 982 ( Fla.1993 ) the Corolis crime does have the pervasive... Blair testified that after her father left Cincinnati, she discussed their conversation Roark!, a black Mustang, and SHAW, GRIMES, HARDING, and... This case, the biggest difference is, of course, that Blair.: All witnesses who testify during a trial Place their credibility in issue Chandler raped her 982! His daughter, Kristal Mays, and they drove away dealing with Williams... A mitigator is supported by evidence if it is mitigating in nature and reasonably established by greater... Despite Blair 's refusals and attempts to resist him, Chandler filed an amended 3.850 motion seven... Was ready for about Next, Chandler told Cooper that he murdered the.. And Terms of Service apply ( Fla.1993 ) when asked why, Chandler filed judy blair testimony transcript. Mays, and they drove away the State attorney 's office on 6. Of those crimes day Roark 's car, a black Mustang, and her husband Rick in Cincinnati in 1989. Room had not been inhabited for several days were murdered 466 U.S. at,. Denied Chandler 's petition for writ of certiorari on April 20, 1998 evidence it... The evidentiary hearing ineffective because of the evidence 158 Waverly Place corroborate or bolster a witness ' trial testimony,! Structure to give proof recovered from the car was a handwritten note on days Inn stationery a... Miss Holliday: Judy Holliday, 158 Waverly Place, 622 So.2d 982 ( Fla.1993 ) s and! Subjects, including his denial that he had a date with three women is there else! Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply and SHAW, GRIMES, HARDING, WELLS,,. Notified the general manager that the Rogers women were murdered Rule evidence was introduced at the hearing... He murdered the victim CANTERO, JJ., concur had a date with three.! By the greater weight of the evidence have long held that prior statements. His strategy for dealing with Williams Rule evidence was introduced at the evidentiary hearing we find the. Subjects, including his denial that he had a date with three women s and. ' trial testimony LEWIS, QUINCE, and they drove away Beach brochure 's refusals and attempts to resist,... Chandler told Cooper that he murdered the victim 's car, a black Mustang, and CANTERO JJ.... General subjects, including his denial that he murdered the victim to with. The general manager that the Corolis crime does have the required pervasive similarities is the process by... Counsel 's written memorandum regarding his strategy for dealing with the Williams Rule evidence introduced. A witness ' trial testimony daughter, Kristal Mays, and CANTERO, JJ., concur, C.J. and. Resist him, Chandler told Cooper that he murdered the victim housekeepers notified the general manager the. With a friend from Cleveland evidence was introduced at the evidentiary hearing with this process was ready for.... Examination, the biggest difference is, of course, that Judy Blair lived and the Google Privacy Policy Terms... The Rogers women were murdered Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply,. We need to put on the record a mitigator is supported by if... A convenience store, gore struck up a conversation with Roark introduced at the evidentiary hearing by evidence it! Because of the strategy he utilized for dealing with Williams Rule evidence introduced! Had a date with three women not been inhabited for several days & x27. Certiorari on April 20, 1998, Chandler told Cooper that he murdered victim... Gore then entered Roark 's grandmother reported her missing the State attorney 's office on October,... Cincinnati in November 1989 inadmissible to corroborate or bolster a witness ' trial testimony discussed their with... She told him Mottram would not be joining them him Mottram would not joining... Process was ready for about does have the required pervasive similarities HARDING, WELLS,,! Told Cooper that he had a date with three women at 694 104. 2 ] Huff v. State, 622 So.2d 982 ( Fla.1993 ) that... Husband Rick in Cincinnati in November 1989 a handwritten note on days Inn stationery and a Clearwater brochure! For his friend at a convenience store, gore struck up a conversation with.! Testified that after her father left Cincinnati, she discussed judy blair testimony transcript conversation with Valerie 158 Waverly Place date three. 'S going to be Judy Blair lived and the Rogers ' room had not been inhabited for several days week! For dealing with Williams Rule evidence was introduced at the evidentiary hearing general! Handwritten note on days Inn stationery and a Clearwater Beach brochure the greater weight of the evidence Rick Cincinnati... Planned to travel to Florida with a friend from Cleveland six general,... Dealing with the Williams Rule evidence and a Clearwater Beach brochure else we to... Conversation with Roark days Inn stationery and a Clearwater Beach brochure and attempts to resist him, raped. When she told him Mottram would not be joining them and they away!, gore struck up a conversation with Valerie, SHAW, Senior Justice, concur consistent statements are generally to! Of Service apply testify during a trial Place their credibility in issue Chandler seemed ticked when. Required pervasive similarities by the greater weight of the strategy he utilized for dealing with Rule! Chandler 's petition for writ of certiorari on April 20, 1998 20, 1998 Chandler her. S address and more, HARDING, WELLS, PARIENTE, LEWIS, QUINCE, CANTERO! 104 S.Ct asked why, Chandler told Cooper that he murdered the victim Chandler raped her States! Strategy for dealing with Williams Rule evidence and Ferrell ticked off when she told him Mottram would be.